Kim Kardashian’s latest venture into acting has sparked a firestorm of criticism, leaving many to wonder: Can reality TV royalty truly conquer the world of scripted drama? Her new legal series, All’s Fair, has premiered to a staggering 0% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, a verdict that’s as brutal as it is rare. But here’s where it gets controversial: Is this a fair assessment of the show’s merits, or is Kardashian’s presence alone enough to skew the reviews? Let’s dive in.
Created by the powerhouse trio of Ryan Murphy, Jon Robin Baitz, and Joe Baken, All’s Fair debuted on Hulu with its first three episodes, promising a bold take on female empowerment in the cutthroat world of divorce law. The series follows a group of fiercely intelligent women who break away from a male-dominated firm to build their own empire. According to the official synopsis, these characters don’t just navigate high-stakes breakups and scandalous secrets—they rewrite the rules of the game. Sounds compelling, right? And this is the part most people miss: the show’s premise is undeniably timely, tapping into broader conversations about gender dynamics and professional ambition.
Starring alongside Kardashian are heavyweights like Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Sarah Paulson, Teyana Taylor, and Glenn Close. With such a star-studded cast, expectations were sky-high. Yet, as of this writing, All’s Fair has earned a 0% “rotten” rating from Rotten Tomatoes critics based on five scathing reviews. The audience score isn’t much kinder, hovering at a tepid 48% on the Popcornmeter—though it’s worth noting that fewer than 50 verified users have weighed in so far.
So, what are the critics saying? Angie Han of The Hollywood Reporter pulls no punches, describing Kardashian’s performance as “stiff and affectless”—a critique that extends to the show’s writing. Lucy Mangan of The Guardian goes even further, calling the series “existentially terrible” and suggesting it borders on contempt for its audience. Ed Power of The Daily Telegraph labels it a “mind-bending horror,” while Ben Dowell of The Times argues that the show fails to deliver on its feminist aspirations, instead becoming a “tacky monument to greed and vanity.”
But here’s the question that’s dividing viewers: Is All’s Fair truly as bad as the reviews suggest, or is Kardashian’s involvement overshadowing the show’s potential? Some argue that the series is being held to an unfair standard simply because of her casting. Others believe the critiques are justified, pointing to what they see as lackluster writing and uneven performances. Is this a case of bias, or is All’s Fair simply a misstep?
New episodes of All’s Fair are set to drop every Tuesday on Hulu through December 9, giving audiences plenty of time to form their own opinions. Whether you’re a Kardashian skeptic or a fan of legal dramas, one thing’s for sure: this show is sparking conversations—and controversies—that won’t be resolved anytime soon. What do you think? Is All’s Fair deserving of its 0% score, or is it being unfairly judged? Let us know in the comments!
